What the reporting says, and the numbers behind it
OpinionSports Illustrated’s Cem Yolbulan wrote that the Jordan Poole trade was “a clear misevaluation of talent from Joe Dumars and the front office.” Sports Illustrated, January 8, 2026
OpinionCBS Sports’ Sam Quinn wrote that Dumars and Weaver “jumped the gun” when they kept a veteran and gave up the unprotected 2026 first, which he called “such a great pick.” CBS Sports, December 11, 2025
No. 8
Where the 2026 pick the Pelicans gave up landed, and it went to Atlanta
Has anyone this bad been hired to run a team again?
Our count of Basketball-Reference’s executive records
Once, for about two months. Of the ten worst records by a team’s top basketball executive since 1976, counting tenures of three or more seasons the team played, only Jack McCloskey ran another team afterward, as Toronto’s stopgap from April 1 to June 7, 2004. Troy Weaver’s 74-244 in Detroit is the fourth worst of all of them, and New Orleans hired him anyway, in 2025, to work under Dumars.
OpinionA record like that does not get anyone hired again after a real search, and Sports Illustrated’s Cem Yolbulan wrote that the Pelicans entrusted Dumars and Weaver to run their basketball operations “without a real hiring process”, with no other candidates and no formal interviews.
Benson named Dumars on April 16, 2025, two days after David Griffin was fired. The Bird Writes reported that there had been “no formal search,” no list of finalists and no reported interviews with rising executives. The Bird Writes, Associated Press
2 days
From David Griffin’s firing to the day Benson named Dumars
OpinionSports Illustrated’s Cem Yolbulan on the two hires: “There were no other candidates, formal interviews, or due diligence.” Sports Illustrated, November 16, 2025
Sources in Detroit told The Athletic’s John Hollinger that no one from the Pelicans called the Pistons to vet Weaver before he was hired, Hoops Rumors reported. Hoops Rumors, November 19, 2025
9 days
From Griffin’s firing on April 14, 2025, to ESPN’s report that the Pelicans had hired Troy Weaver
Tenures of three or more seasons since 1976 at .330 or lower, worst first
Executive
Team and years
Record
Winning pct.
Ran another team later
Sam Hinkie
Philadelphia, 2013-16
47-199
.191
No
Michael Winger
Washington, 2023 to now
50-196
.203
Still in the job
Stu Jackson
Vancouver, 1994-2000
78-300
.206
No
Troy Weaver
Detroit, 2020-24
74-244
.233
No, but New Orleans hired him in 2025 to work under Dumars
Jack McCloskey
Minnesota, 1992-95
60-186
.244
Toronto, 2004, for about two months as a stopgap
Harry Weltman
New Jersey, 1987-90
62-184
.252
No
David Kahn
Minnesota, 2009-13
89-223
.285
No
Steve Mills
New York, 2017-20
67-163
.291
No
Chris Grant
Cleveland, 2010-14
97-215
.311
No
Bernie Bickerstaff
Charlotte, 2003-07
77-169
.313
No
Robert Salyers
Indiana, 1981-86
129-281
.315
No
Jerry Reynolds
Sacramento, 1989-94
130-280
.317
No
Garry St. Jean
Golden State, 1997-2004
172-370
.317
No
Rob Hennigan
Orlando, 2012-17
132-278
.322
No
Phil Jackson
New York, 2014-17
80-166
.325
No
Billy Knight
Atlanta, 2003-08
134-276
.327
No
John Nash
Washington, 1990-96
161-331
.327
Yes: New Jersey, 1999-2000, and Portland, 2003-06
Method: our count from the Basketball-Reference executives index and each franchise’s season-by-season records there. Years are as Basketball-Reference lists them, and a tenure listed as 2020-24 is credited with the seasons ending in 2021 through 2024. Only tenures of three or more seasons the team played that began in 1976 or later count, and the current season is left out. A season in which the executive changed partway through is credited whole, so a few records may be off by a few games. Counting listed years instead would add Carl Scheer’s 39-125 in Charlotte and Isiah Thomas’s 51-113 in Toronto, expansion tenures that began before their teams’ first seasons, and would not change the findings above.
Dumars’s last six seasons in Detroit
2008-0939-43
2009-1027-55
2010-1130-52
2011-1225-41
2012-1329-53
2013-1429-53
The line on each bar marks an even record.
That is 179-297 in all, six straight losing seasons to end his time in Detroit, where his teams had won the 2004 title. The Pelicans’ own announcement says he spent three seasons in the Sacramento Kings front office, from 2019 to 2022, and Basketball-Reference lists him as the Kings’ top basketball executive for about five weeks in 2020. He worked at the NBA league office from 2022 until New Orleans hired him. The Pelicans under Dumars are 31-67: 26-56 in the 2025-26 season and 5-11 this season, as of November 19, 2026.
Jack McCloskey, the one person in the ten worst who ran another team afterward, had built Detroit’s championship teams before he went 60-186 in Minnesota, and his time running Toronto in 2004 lasted from April 1 to June 7, as a stopgap.
Mitch Kupchak is a case like Dumars’s. His last four Lakers seasons went 91-237 (27-55, 21-61, 17-65 and 26-56, a season in which the Lakers replaced him in February) before Charlotte hired him in 2018, and he had won championships with the Lakers. His losing run lasted four seasons, and Dumars’s lasted six.
The Pelicans fired David Griffin, and that same day the Associated Press reported that the team had already held talks to gauge Joe Dumars’s interest in the job, while ESPN reported that Dumars was a leading candidate to replace him.
Two days after the firing, owner Gayle Benson named Dumars executive vice president of basketball operations, hiring him from the NBA league office, where he had run basketball operations since 2022, and said her decision was “not hastily made.”
The Bird Writes noted there had been “no formal search” and no list of finalists.
Seven months later, Hoops Rumors reported that the Pelicans “didn’t conduct an extensive search” before hiring Dumars, according to The Athletic’s John Hollinger.
OpinionThe Athletic’s Christian Clark wrote on November 19, 2026, that “hiring Dumars without conducting any sort of comprehensive search was baffling.”
ESPN reported that the Pelicans hired Troy Weaver as senior vice president of basketball operations under Dumars, and the team confirmed the hire on May 28.
Weaver had spent four seasons as general manager of the Detroit Pistons, who went 20-52, 23-59, 17-65 and 14-68 under him, 74-244 in all.
The Pelicans agreed to send CJ McCollum, Kelly Olynyk and a future second-round pick to Washington for Jordan Poole, Saddiq Bey and the No. 40 pick in the 2025 draft.
On draft night the Pelicans moved up ten spots to No. 13 to take Derik Queen, and they paid Atlanta the No. 23 pick plus their 2026 first-round pick, which was the better of their own and Milwaukee’s and carried no protection at all.
In the N.O. reported that the Pelicans never announced a role for Joe Dumars’s son, Jordan, and confirmed that he works as a basketball operations consultant only after the newsletter asked.
A team spokesperson called his absence from the staff listing an oversight that would be corrected, and a later note from the newsletter said the team lists no consultants in its directory as a matter of policy.
The Pelicans finished the 2025-26 season 26-56 and missed the playoffs, after firing coach Willie Green at 2-10 and going 24-46 under interim coach James Borrego.
Roundtable and Sports Illustrated, following a first report by In the N.O., reported that staff were told by email that their contracts would not be renewed, that the changes left at least 25 vacancies across basketball operations and business departments, some of them from people who left on their own, and that the analytics department was “completely gutted.”
On November 19, 2026, The Athletic’s Christian Clark reported, “Former team employees have told The Athletic they were fired via email.”
In June, Crescent City Sports reported that the team hired Amanda Green, who spent 11 years with the Oklahoma City Thunder, as executive director of strategy and analytics.
At the draft lottery the Pelicans’ own pick dropped one spot to No. 8 and Milwaukee’s landed at No. 10, so the 2026 pick the Pelicans had given up was their own, and it went to Atlanta, leaving the Pelicans with no first-round pick in the 2026 draft.
Dejounte Murray asked to be traded, and the Pelicans confirmed the request and said they would weigh offers that serve the team, the Associated Press reported.
The Athletic’s Christian Clark wrote on November 19, 2026, that multiple league sources, speaking anonymously, have reached out to him “wondering why Dumars’ son, Jordan, is so involved in the day-to-day decision-making” with the Pelicans.
Three days after he traded an unprotected 2026 first-round pick to move up for Derik Queen, Dumars answered the trade’s critics at the news conference introducing the team’s rookies by saying “We’re going to trod our own path here”, Sports Illustrated reported.
What happened next
What happened: The pick he gave up was unprotected and the better of the Pelicans’ own and Milwaukee’s, in a 2026 draft that Pelican Debrief’s Andy Quach wrote that week was “expected to have several heavy hitters”. It landed at No. 8 in the May 2026 lottery and went to Atlanta, which left the Pelicans with no first-round pick in that draft.
What happened: Before that interview, in January 2026, Sports Illustrated, citing ClutchPoints’ Brett Siegel, reported that league executives said the Pelicans had not traded either player because they were not getting enough value and because of their asking price: three first-round picks for Trey Murphy III and two for Herb Jones, plus young players. In July 2026, Sports Illustrated’s Cem Yolbulan wrote that the Pelicans had turned down all trade offers and reportedly had “a prohibitively high asking price”. The Pelicans have since lost six games in a row on the way to a 5-11 start, and on November 13 Dejounte Murray asked to be traded.
OpinionAfter the Poole trade and the draft-night trade drew so much ridicule, the front office has held out for a price no team has met, while the losses pile up.
What the league is saying
Writing about where Dejounte Murray could be traded, CBS Sports’ Sam Quinn said the Pelicans are probably hesitant to give up first-round draft compensation to move him to Charlotte “after all of the criticism they (justifiably) received” for the 2025 draft-night trade.
The Lead’s Yasmeen Hasan wrote that after the team brought back nearly the same roster, talent has not been the Pelicans’ main problem, and that they will keep landing in this position “so long as they lack strong leadership”.
Sports Illustrated’s David Grubb wrote that Joe Dumars and Troy Weaver assembled the roster and that “Their decisions deserve as much scrutiny as the coach’s substitutions.”