Fire Joe Dumars

The Saints

The Saints front office

30-47

The Saints since Sean Payton left, through November 15, 2026. They have not reached the playoffs since the 2020 season.

  1. Sean Payton, 15 seasons 152-89
  2. Since Payton left 30-47
  3. Dennis Allen, 2022 to November 2024 18-25
  4. The rest of 2024, after Allen was fired 3-5
  5. 2025, Kellen Moore’s first season 6-11
  6. This season, through November 15, 2026 3-6

The line on each bar marks an even record.

Who makes the football decisions

This page sets the Saints’ biggest football decisions since Sean Payton left after the 2021 season next to the results that followed, and it names who made each one. Every fact links to public reporting or an official record, and every opinion is labeled.

Who makes the football decisions

The Saints’ official site lists Mickey Loomis as “Executive Vice President/General Manager” and calls him “Responsible for the club’s entire football operations”. His biography names coaching, player personnel and scouting, salary cap management and contract negotiations among the departments under his direction, and it says he arrived in 2000 and was promoted to general manager in 2002.

When the team was 1-4 in October 2026, owner Gayle Benson said Loomis and the football staff are responsible for “building a roster capable of sustained success”, FOX 8 reported.

Since Payton left, the Saints have gone 30-47 through November 15, 2026, and they have not reached the playoffs since the 2020 season. That count adds Dennis Allen’s 18-25, the 3-5 finish to the 2024 season after he was fired, the 6-11 of 2025 and the 3-6 of this season.

Sources: Saints: Mickey Loomis biography, FOX 8, Associated Press, via KSAT, Sports Illustrated, Saints, FOX 8

The decisions, in order

  1. Sean Payton told the team he was leaving after 15 seasons, a 152-89 regular-season record and nine playoff appearances. The Saints had just gone 9-8 and narrowly missed the playoffs. Loomis promoted defensive coordinator Dennis Allen to replace him.

    Sources: Associated Press, via News4Jax, Associated Press, via KSAT

  2. Quarterback Derek Carr agreed to a four-year contract with the Saints, and the Associated Press, citing a person familiar with the situation, reported that the deal could be worth up to $150 million.

    Source: Associated Press, via KSAT

  3. The Saints fired Allen a day after a loss at Carolina extended their losing streak to seven games, their longest since 1999, and left them 2-7. Allen went 18-25 without a playoff appearance.

    Source: Associated Press, via KSAT

  4. Over the Cap’s Jason Fitzgerald estimated that the Saints sat about $63 million over the next year’s salary cap, a position $55 million worse than the next closest NFL team, and that they already led the league in dead money with $48 million on the books. He counted nearly 50 restructured contracts, almost 25 more than the next closest team, and wrote that from 2020 to 2024 the Saints restructured around $450 million to create nearly $340 million in cap space.

    Source: Over the Cap

    OpinionEach restructure moved part of a contract’s cost into later seasons, and those seasons arrived without a playoff team to show for it.

  5. The Saints introduced Kellen Moore as head coach after what Loomis called “a comprehensive process”, and Sports Illustrated later described Moore as “the handpicked coach of longtime general manager Mickey Loomis”. The Saints went 6-11 in his first season and are 3-6 in his second. More is on the Kellen Moore page.

    Sources: Saints, Sports Illustrated, FOX 8

  6. The Saints placed Carr on the reserve/retired list, formalizing the retirement he announced on May 10. Pro Football Rumors reported that the Saints waited until after June 1 so they could spread $50.132 million in dead money across two years, $19.207 million in 2025 and the remaining $30.925 million after that.

    Source: Pro Football Rumors

    OpinionThe 2023 contract produced no playoff games and left the Saints paying for a quarterback who was no longer on the roster.

  7. The 2025 season ended at 6-11, which the Saints’ own site called “the franchise’s fifth straight year missing the playoffs”.

    Source: Saints

  8. Carolina beat the Saints 20-17, leaving them 3-6 this season and 1-4 at the Caesars Superdome.

    Source: FOX 8

They said, then what happened

  1. When Carr signed, Loomis said his “experience, leadership and skillset will be an asset to our offense”.

    What happened: The Saints missed the playoffs in 2023 and 2024, Allen was fired at 2-7 in November 2024, and Carr’s retirement left $50.132 million in dead money spread over two years.

    Sources: Associated Press, via KSAT, FOX 8, Associated Press, via KSAT, Pro Football Rumors

  2. With the Saints at 2-8, Benson told The Times-Picayune, “When I am asked to hold Mickey Loomis accountable, I do”, and added, “Not every decision works out”, Sports Illustrated reported.

    What happened: The Saints finished 6-11, their fifth straight year without the playoffs, and they are 3-6 this season.

    Sources: Sports Illustrated, Saints, FOX 8

  3. At a news conference that FOX 8 said was dominated by questions about Benson’s criticism, Loomis said, “This is an outcome-based sport, and it’s not good enough yet”. Asked about benchmarks for this season, he said they were “a little more subjective” and added, “I’d rather not get into the specifics of that”.

    What happened: The Saints were 2-4 that week. They have gone 1-2 since and are 3-6.

    Sources: FOX 8, FOX 8

Who answers for this

OpinionLoomis has run the Saints’ football operations since 2002. The coach who replaced Payton, the quarterback contract and the cap plan were all decided under him, and the Saints have not reached the playoffs since the 2020 season. Benson called firing him ridiculous, and she has also said the responsibility starts with her. After five straight years without the playoffs, she should say what result would change her mind, and he should say what progress looks like this season.

Sources: Saints: Mickey Loomis biography, Sports Illustrated, FOX 8

Gayle Benson’s decisions

Questions they should answer

Ask Mickey Loomis

  1. Asked in October about benchmarks for this season, you said you would rather not get into the specifics. What record would count as progress this season?

    Source: FOX 8

  2. Over the Cap counted nearly 50 restructured contracts by November 2024, almost 25 more than the next closest team. How many more have you restructured since then, and how much salary has moved into later seasons?

    Source: Over the Cap

  3. How much dead money do the Saints carry this season, and how much is already committed for next season?

    Sources: Over the Cap, Pro Football Rumors

  4. Benson said you and the football staff are responsible for building a roster capable of sustained success. After five straight seasons without the playoffs, which of your moves since 2022 do you think have worked?

    Source: FOX 8

Ask Gayle Benson

  1. With the team at 2-8 last season, you said firing Mickey Loomis was ridiculous. At 3-6 this season, do you still think so?

    Source: Sports Illustrated

  2. In October you said, “I am responsible for holding this organization accountable”. By which season do you expect the Saints back in the playoffs, and what happens if they are not?

    Source: FOX 8

Sources

Gayle Benson Kellen Moore Game-day prices